A Comparative Study of the Beneficial Effects of Ipratropium and Beclomethasone against Insulin-Induced Tracheal Tissue Contraction in a Guinea Pig Model

OBJECTIVE To evaluate the acute effects of insulin on airway reactivity and the protective effects of beclomethasone and ipratropium against insulin-induced airway hyperresponsiveness on isolated tracheal smooth muscle in a guinea pig model. MATERIALS AND METHODS The trachea of each guinea pig was excised; one end of the tracheal strip was attached to the hook of the oxygen tube of a tissue bath and the other end was connected to a research-grade isometric force displacement transducer. The effects of varying concentrations of insulin (10(-7) to 10(-3)M) and insulin pretreated with a fixed concentration of beclomethasone (10(-6)M) and ipratropium (10(-6)M) on the isolated tracheal tissue were studied by constructing cumulative concentration-response curves. Changes in tracheal smooth muscle contractions were recorded on a 4-channel oscillograph. RESULTS The means ± standard error of the mean of the maximum amplitude of contraction with increasing concentrations of insulin and of insulin pretreated with fixed concentrations of beclomethasone and ipratropium were 35 ± 1.13, 22 ± 1.15 and 27.8 ± 1.27 mm, respectively. CONCLUSION The data showed that beclomethasone inhibited the contractile response of insulin to a greater extent than ipratropium. Thus we suggest that inhalational insulin pretreated with beclomethasone may be more efficacious than with ipratropium for the amelioration of potential respiratory adverse effects such as bronchoconstriction.